The 5 Best PEI Wedding Cakes and Desserts
A wedding cake is more than just a dessert — it’s the centerpiece of your reception and a scrumptious portrait of your love story. Want to have an elegant multi-tiered cake? A trendy dessert alternative? Or something completely custom? Good news! Prince Edward Island has some of the finest and most creative wedding cake bakeries to seal the deal in the sweetest way.
Beyond the aesthetic, your wedding cake is also about flavor and experience. The moment you cut into it, share that first bite with your partner, and hear the delighted reactions from your guests — it’s a memory in the making.
Want to know which ones are the best PEI wedding cakes and desserts? Here are my top picks:
1. Ellie’s Cakes (@elliebakescakes.pei)
Ellie is truly a magician when it comes to custom wedding cakes in Prince Edward Island. Her designs are elegant, sophisticated, and completely customizable to match your wedding theme. Ellie’s Cakes delivers stunning results every time, whether you go for a classic white-tiered cake with delicate florals or a modern masterpiece with bold colors.
What makes Ellie’s Cakes special? Her attention to detail and ability to craft cakes that look almost too good to eat! She also stays ahead of wedding cake trends, offering everything from nature-inspired cakes to classy minimalism. If you’re looking for a breathtaking wedding cake and a lovely baker behind it, Ellie is your go-to.
2. Revilo Cakes (@revilocakes)
Revilo Cakes brings creativity and artistry to their unique wedding cake designs in PEI. They are always pushing the boundaries with innovative flavors and knockout designs. If you want something that stands out, like a hand-painted cake or one adorned with realistic, delicate flowers, this is the bakery for you.
One of the things I love about Revilo Cakes is their willingness to experiment. They’re not afraid to step outside the traditional cake box, offering themed cakes, shiny effects, and even vintage finishes. Whether you want a whimsical fairy tale cake or a sleek, modern design, they can make it happen.
3. Get Caked Donuts (@getcakeddonuts)
Not a fan of traditional wedding cakes? How about a donut tower instead? Get Caked Donuts puts the fun in the PEI dessert catering for weddings. Their gourmet donuts are perfect for couples looking for a dessert alternative to wedding cakes in Prince Edward Island.
Imagine a beautifully arranged display of handcrafted donuts, dripping in delicious glazes and topped with everything from fresh fruit to crumbled cookies. These donuts are not only delicious but also create a laid-back, interactive dessert experience for your guests. With their classic flavors like salted caramel or fun options like butter tart or cotton candy, these donuts will be a hit at your wedding.
4. For Real Dough (@for.realdough)
Real Dough is hands down one of the greatest wedding cakes in Charlottetown, PEI. Their cakes are not only beautiful but also incredibly delicious. Kelsey creates everything from classic tiered cakes to modern, minimalist designs.
One of the best things about For Real Dough is their range of options; if you’re now into the idea of not having a traditional cake, you can choose from macaroons, cookies, brownies, cupcakes, chocolate bombs, you name it. Also, if you or your guests have specific dietary needs, they offer gluten-free or vegan wedding desserts without sacrificing taste or texture.
If you want a cake that not only looks dreamy but also melts in your mouth, For Real Dough is a must. Every time I work with them, I know the cake will be a showstopper!
5. The Willow Bakery & Cafe (@thewillowbakerypei)
If you’re looking for a cozy, locally loved bakery that serves up some of the tastiest Prince Edward Island wedding desserts, The Willow Bakery & Cafe is a must-visit. Their mini-tarts, cupcakes, and other sweet treats are perfect for intimate weddings or as part of a dessert table.
Everything on their menu is absolutely delicious, so you can’t go wrong here. The creativity and attention to detail they put into their flavors and dessert decoration are unparalleled. Besides, The Willow Bakery & Cafe can cater to dietary restrictions to make sure everyone enjoys all the goodness.
Most Popular Wedding Cake Flavors in PEI
Choosing the right flavor is just as important as picking the design! Some of the most popular flavors for wedding cakes in Prince Edward Island include:
- Classic Vanilla Bean with Raspberry Compote – Light, delicate, and timeless.
- Decadent Chocolate with Salted Caramel – A crowd-pleaser with rich and indulgent layers.
- Lemon Elderflower – A fresh, floral choice perfect for summer weddings.
- Red Velvet with Cream Cheese Frosting – A beautiful and flavorful option that always impresses.
- Local Blueberry or Strawberry Shortcake-Inspired Cakes – A nod to PEI’s fresh, local ingredients.
If you are looking for gluten-free or vegan wedding desserts, here are some options to consider:
- Vegan Chocolate Avocado Cake – Moist, rich, and completely dairy-free.
- Almond Flour Vanilla Cake with Coconut Frosting – Light and nutty with a subtle sweetness.
- Gluten-Free Lemon Poppy Seed Cake – A zesty option with a soft crumb and bright flavor.
More Unique Wedding Dessert Ideas
With so many options, it’s easy to understand if you want to ditch the traditional wedding cakes. But no worries, here are some dessert alternatives to wedding cakes that your guests will love:
- Macaroon Towers – Elegant, colorful, and light.
- Mini Cheesecakes – Individual servings of creamy perfection.
- Pie Bars – A cozy and rustic option for fall weddings.
- Ice Cream Sandwiches – Fun and nostalgic for summer weddings.
- Cupcake Displays – Perfect for guests to grab and enjoy.
I hope my top wedding cake bakeries in PEI list has helped you decide which dessert to pick. Whether you want a classic, modern, or completely unique dessert, PEI has some of the most talented bakers ready to make your celebration ever sweeter.
And when it comes to capturing every beautiful detail, I’m here to help! I’d love to be your PEI wedding photographer and help you plan the most important day of your life. Get in touch and let’s make your dream wedding come true!
